Caterer Reviews
Join Our Family of Customers

Colby's Pig Roast Catering Inc. 1254 Rush Scottsville Road, Rush, NY 14543 (585) 533-2310

Colby's Catered over 4,600 events
For These Customers Since 1989  
9th Grade Acadamy
ABBEC Manufacturing
Ace Swim & Leisure
Action Protective Group
Action Townig Service
Admar Supply
ADT Security
Association of Facility Engineers
Alton Manufacturing
Amer. Legion Penfield
Amer. Legion Williamson
American Express
American Filtration
American Legion Post 468
American Legion Rush
AMF Lanes
Anchor Christian Church
Applied Energy Solutions
Arndt Funeral Home
Asbury First Unt. Church
Avon United Methodist Church
AXA Financial Services
B. J. Muirhead Co.
Baker Commodities
Bellows Rochester Rehab Center
Benefit Resources
Bergen Fire Dept.
Bishop Kearney High School
Bohn's Rest. Batavia
Boy Scouts of America
Brockport Ambulance
Brockport Yatch Club
Browncroft Community  Church
Bucci Auto Service
Caldwell Construction
Camping World Inc.
Canandaigua Yacht Club
 Career Systems Development
Central Presbyterian Church
Centre Point Golf Club
Chase Bank
Chase Corporate Challenge
Chili Fire Department
Citi Bank
Citizens Bank
City of Rochester Water Bureau
College Green Apartments
Corning Inc
County Wide Homes
Covenant Life Church
Cross Creek Church
Dan Farley Contracting
Double Tree
Ducks Unlimited
EAA Chapter 44
Eastman Kodak
Edwards Electric
  Elim Bible Institute
EMA Design
 Fast Trak Construction
Felucca Door Co.
Ferris Hills
Finger Lakes Race Track
First Genesis Baptist Church
Flower City Masonry
Foxy's Night Club
Gamma Epsilon Tau
Gates Rec. Dept.
Gates Vol. Ambulance
Genesee Reserve Supply
Genesee Waterways
Geneseo Girls Lacrosse
Ginna Nuclear Power Plant
Global Crossing
Golden Agers of Chili
Good Sheppard School
Gravel Ponds
Gray Bar Electric
Greece Democratic Party
Greece Methodist Church
Greece School District
Gro-Moore Farms
Gyro Club
Hampton Inn
Harris Corporation
Hen Reg. Baptist Church
Henrietta Bus Garage
Henrietta Moose Lodge
Holiday Inn Airport
Home Depot
Honeoye Falls Lima School District
Honeoye Falls -Lima Schools Transportation
Horizon Solutions
Hudson Steel
Innovative Catering Supply
Iron. Bay Fish & Game
Irondequoit Historical Society
J. Kozel & Son
Jamro Auto Repair
Javlyn Inc.
Jefferson Estates
John Betlem Heating
Jutzin School 50 RCSD
Kasa Enterprises
Kings & Queens Club
Kittelbergers Florist
Kraft Foods
Lake Shore Hockey Arena
Land Tech
Laurelton Fire Dept.
LDL Pools
Lewis Tree Service
Lexington Machining
Livonia Junior Bulldogs
Locust Hill Country Club
Lowe's Home Improvement
Macedon Excavating
Mercy flight Central
MG Car Club
Mon. County Dist. Attorney
Monroe County Abate
Monroe County DES
Monroe County Sheriff
Monroe County Water Authority
Monroe Vol. Firefighters
Neutral Ground
North Greece Fire Dept.
NYS Dept. of Labor
NYS Troopers
Oak Hill Country Club
Odd Fellows Lodge
Olympia High School
Onondagua Community College
Ontario Plastics
Pactiv Corporation
Perinton Seniors
Perinton Youth Hockey
Philips Lighting
Pittsford Mendon H.S.
Point Pleasant Fire Dept.
Polish Heritage Society
Proiettis Rest.
R-H Lacrosse H.S. Team
RIT Biomedical Science
RIT Food Service
RIT Gamma Epsilon
Rochester Curling Club
Rochester Home Builders Assn.
Rochester Lumber
Rochester Police Dept.
Rochester Protective's
Rochester RR
Rochester Rugby Club
Rochester Yacht Club
Rochester Youth Camps
Rochester Youth Hockey
Romano Rolmold Inc.
Rual Metro Ambulance
 Rush Fire Dept.
Rush Henrietta Bus
Rush Henrietta H. S.
Rush Henrietta Sperry High
S & D Automotive
Sage Rutty and Co.
Saint Ambrose Church
Saint Thomas Aquines
Schantz Homes
Schlegel Systems
Scottsville Ice Arena
Sienna Academy
Sodus Yacht Club
Southerland Group
Spencerport Depot and Museum
SPS Medical
 St. Ann's Home
St. John Fisher College
St. Pius X Church
SUNY Brockport
Superior Technology
Teale Machine Company
The Infield
The Villas at Chestnut Ridge
Thermo RGL
Townshed Associates
Tuesday Club #3
Twin District Auxiliary
Twisted Sisters
Union Hill Fire Dept.
United Auto Workers
United Commercial Trvl
Unity Health
University of Rochester
Upstate Auto
USA Hockey c/o Advance Arena
Village Sports
VP Supply Corp.
Warren-Whalin Property Management
Waste Management
Watkins Glenn 
Webster Fire Department
Webster Lions Club
Webster Parks and Rec.
Webster Wholesale Tire
Wegmans Food
Wendy's Restaurants
West Gates Seniors
West Group
Western Monroe Historical Society
Westgate Seniors
Willow Group
Wood Specialties
Worldwide Electric Corp.
and hundreds  of other private family parties, social groups and businesses!
You did it again! You made another couple's dreams come true with your wedding magic. Aaron and I wanted to thank you for going above and beyond. With your cheerful smile and optimistic demeanor, you were a pleasure to do business with. Between coordinating the barn set-up, pig roast, and dessert, you took a big burden of stress off our shoulders. We had a dream wedding reception and everyone had a blast!
Val & Aaron

Thank you again for all you did to make my daughter's Saturday wedding at the Barn a magical event, everyone had wonderful, amazing comments about your food. We were so thrilled to be able to have Colby's cater our event. Best wishes always!
The Weinsteins

To anyone looking for an event venue:
Last year my two youngest daughters were married. One in May the other in October.
Both decided to celebrate their special day at the Wedding Barn.
They could not have made a better choice. Jim Kolb was SO nice and easy to work with.
He and his staff are the embodiment of a “can-do” attitude. The barn itself combines a rustic
setting with all of the modern services one would expect from a “fancy” party house.
One daughter was married on the deck and the other at the gazebo. Both locations were ideal
romantic settings.
For me, as host, the best feature is the staff itself. Jim is VERY eager to please and such a NICE
guy and his staff mirrors his personality. They go out of their way to honor any request and ensure
that you have all your needs met. The Nashville Bar personnel who cater the drinks were every bit
as nice (and made sure that I always had a cold Coke ready when needed).
Even a shift in weather conditions, which had us changing from gazebo to balcony and back to
gazebo for the second wedding, did not faze the staff. They had everything moved and ready to go
within 15 min.!
If you are considering the Barn, my message to you is “Book it! Just Book It!”
You'll be purchasing wonderful memories spent at a unique and equally wonderful place.
Gary Knight

I would like to thank you for the great food. The hockey party was a hit, thanks to the pork and chicken. The sausage was the talk of the party. Great food, Thank you for your hard work and great food,
Rich Krenzer

Thank you so much for your donation of a free ice cream cone for each of the children participating in our Summer Reading Program. These gifts encourage the children to continue to read during the summer months. We truly appreciate your continued support of the Rush Public Library.
Joan Celentano and the Rush Staff

Thank you so very much for a wonderful job on May 10 with the food that was furnished for the Lima Golden Age Club. Everyone enjoyed!
Merilyn Stuart
President of the Golden Age Club

We want to thank you so much for making our day so special. Everything was beautiful and went off without a hitch (thanks to you). Thank you for being so accommodating and pleasant to work with. We wish you much success with your future weddings/parties.
Lori & Keith Moranda

We are so grateful for everyone's hard work and kindness at the Wedding Barn. Our guests, especially those visiting from China, thought the venue and festivities were amazing - everyone loved Colby's Catering! Thank you so much for making the day fun and special for us and our guests.
Shelly & Yuan

Thank you for all the work you put into making our wedding special. We had such an amazing day - the barn was gorgeous, the food was delicious, and everything went so smoothly. Thank you especially for the extra shaved ice bar! That was sweet of you​ to include on such a hot day, we loved it!
Sue & John Tapee

I'm a 3rd generation farmer and I'm hard to impress. I had wedding at your place 8-8-15 I don't do the internets but wanted to thank you. I booked your Barn early on before the deck and other improvements. We had a large crowd and everything you said you were going to do you accomplished with professional quality. Food, atmosphere, bar and dj could not have been better. Thanks again, you may give out my phone number for reference for future events . The thing I appreciate the most is if I called you answered the phone and took care of business.
Pete Conrow

The food was incredible, the meat was moist and delicious! The sides were tasty, loved the broccoli salad. I almost did not get it because I usually don't like broccoli, very happy with all the choices for sides
Food Experience I can't say enough good things about the food!!! We got the whole pig and if you ever get a chance to do that I highly recommend it! Not only was it a photo op, it was done to perfection!! And the mac and cheese was a huge hit!! We had a lot of children at the wedding and it was a favorite of kids and adults
Staff experience I don't remember the name, but he was quick and efficient, it was a lot of food for just over a 100 people and the trays were never empty. He was friendly and answered questions I had
ordering and website It was easy to order online, the hardest part was to make choices!! I would definitely recommend Colby's to anyone planning an event

Thank you all for putting such a lovely reception together for Andy and I. We had a great time! The food reallywas delicious (went back for 2nds!) The cake was incredible. The space was well used, set up and take down was great. Our guests had a wonderful time on the dance floor and relaxing on the deck. Thank you for all you hard work! Blesses on you & your Business.
Michelle & Andy Yestrebi

By chance, this was the third time in a week I enjoyed Colby's the quality and consistency of the food and service was spot on.
We changed it up for our rehearsal dinner and tried some different sides. The mac and cheese was a big hit! Lots of leftovers that are in the freezer ready for our next get together.I had a little trouble booking on line, called Kim and got it worked out.Excellent - Everything went great event was perfectExcellent- Your driver was on time, friendly and efficient. I ordered all the party supplies and was not disappointed. They were very helpful and friendly to our guestsBuffet Delivery and set-up
K Dentin Gram Corp.

Kim & Jim
Our sons graduation party was perfect! Your website was very easy to navigate! The food was delicious, people raved about it. Picked up package came easy to set up! couldn't have been more pleased! Thank you for making this enjoyable 
Mike and Danna Shane

The wedding and food were absolutely wonderful and I thank you for your welcoming atmosphere at the Barn. Our guests thought the food was the best buffet they every had!! Everyone was also impressed with the beautiful barn.
Thank you for your commitment to making wonderful events,
Marcia B.

Kim and Jim,
I wanted to thank you for doing such a great job at our picnic on July 25th. People are still raving about the food and I’ve already referred one person in your direction for an event they are planning. The food and service was excellent!
I’ll be sure to contact you for our next event.
Thanks again and best regards.
Wendy - Xerox Corp

Hi Kim & Jim 
Again Good Job! Everyone left happy & satisfied... Food was perfect - A big thank you to you both 
Fe & Ron Noble

Kim & Jim
​Wanted to let you know how pleased we were with our dinner from you in quality and quantity. We will be back for more!
Shelley and Fred Gay

Dear Kim 
Our wedding in the barn was absolutely perfect! We wanted a casual, rustic
feel and there was no better place to have our reception. The barn is in the
perfect location (set in the middle of a pumpkin patch and next to an ice
cream/BBQ shop). Our photographer had so many beautiful shots, both inside
and outside, to chose from. Our bridal party and friends danced and sang our
hearts out all night long on the dance floor in the middle of the barn,
while other guests watched from the multiple levels. The charming feeling of
the barn was overwhelming. Thank you for offering such a unique, affordable
place to have rustic weddings in the Rochester Area!
-Monica Phillips

We recently had you prepare the food for our annual summer picnic and I had to write to compliment you! Everyone loved the food and we all felt that it was a great value for what you charged. We were very impressed by the freshness of everything and there was enough food that we could probably have fed 20 more people!!! Everyone went home with lots of leftovers and thought that was a great benefit. Thank you so much for doing such a superb job.
Henrietta Garden Club

Dear Kim and Jim,
The Scott family wants to send their hearty thanks for one of the best meals we have ever enjoyed on Thanksgiving day for our large gathering. I have been one of the chief cooks for this holiday in the past years. After hearing your ad on WYSL Radio in Avon(1040 am), I decided to take a break. Now, I really feel it will become a tradition. The meal was hot, delicious, outstanding turkey!, and the pies, especially the mince pie, were memorable.
I do hope you both had some time to put your feet up after preparing so many meals for your patrons. Again, I plan to continue my patronage for years to come and to share the tales of your great service and delicious food.
Thanks and may the coming year bless you both with good business and cheer.
Wendy Hall, Dr. WV Hall and the Scott family and friends.

Hi Kim 
Last year you catered our parish annual volunteer party - everything was fantastic! We would like to have you cater this year's party as well, We would like the piggy Party #1 for approximately 220 guests - delivered. Thank you so much for all you cooperation and I am looking forward to hearing from you,
Vicki I.  - Peace of Christ Parish 

Dear Colby's 
Thank you so much for the delicious Thanksgiving meal that you catered. Everything was so well preparedand packed, it was a wonderful experience and I will certianly spread the word and come back again
Leslie Koster 

Kim and Jim,
I just wanted to take a minute to thank you and your staff for an absolutely fantastic showing at our Mother's 80th birthday party last Saturday. The food was out of this world and there was plenty of it. (I'm still eating pulled pork!) Between my Sister, Mother and I, we heard nothing but raves about how cool it was to actually see the pig on the spit as they came in, s/he was certainly the star of the show (outside of our Mom of course:) Jim they also commented about the great job you did setting everything up. Very neat and efficient! The food was not only very good, it was fresh, hot and different. The broccoli salad was a huge hit and everybody commented about the beans. I don't think many people put ground round in beans, it was just enough to make it unique. I can tell you no one went home hungry!
Returning to work everyone asked me how it went and I didn't hesitate one second to tell them "perfectly", worth every penny and more. I also won't hesitate to call or recommend Colby's in the future for all the reasons stated above. Thanks again for a great job, it was a perfect day all the way around for our Mom.
Vicki from Surrey Hill

Dear Jim and Kim,
  This note is thank you both so much for yet another amazing pig roast. I read the reviews from other patrons and they have all said both individually and collectively what El and I feel regarding your events. The food was unparalleled as well as the set up and delivery. Our guests were so pleased and very satisfied and complimentary regarding the food and varied menu. Everyone left full and happy!
  Thanks again for making our outing so memorable and for all of the great attention to detail. This was our 5th booking with you and we, as well as others, will certainly be contacting you again as the need arises.
  Many blessings to you and your family and as always, my love and prayers to Jeremy.
Warmest regards,
Donna and El 

I have such great compliments for Colby's. We recently had a pig roast catered by Jim at our new home in Macedon. The food was fantastic! Then we had the ice cream! OMG!!! It is the BEST ice cream I have ever had! Absolutely delicious! Not only the food, but the timing was right on and there were absolutely no worries!
thank you Jim! We will always have you in the future and will always recommend Colby's!
Joe Rowley
Buckingham Properties

Dear Jim & Kim!
What delicious food! My husband recently brought home food from a catered luncheon at B&B Manufacturing in Avon. All I can say is “WOW”! If the leftovers tasted that good, I can imagine how super the food was when it was served earlier that day! We had some of your pulled-pork, chicken legs, broccoli salad, baked beans, potato salad and that luscious Apple- cornbread! Talk about melt in your mouth! I don’t think I’ve ever had any cornbread that was soooo delicious before!
I am sold on your home cookin’ with a definitely down-home style! I intend to tell everyone about you and your gastronomical delights! Keep on cookin’, we’ll all keep on eatin’!
A very satisfied by-stander, 
Grace Johnson, Avon N.Y.

Jim and Kim, 
Thank you for the delicious pork and chicken meal on Saturday. Our family enjoyed all the extras.. potatoes, pasta dish, salad, fruit etc. Your dedication to servicing the best food in Rochester is much appreciated. My prayers for your continuied success.
God Bless You,
Sister Concepta 

Jim and Kim, 
Thank you so much for coming to Buffalo to cater our party. The pig was a hit. The meal was delicious. The set up was smooth. The service was outstanding. The attention to detail was great. …and there are plenty of leftovers to enjoy at my daughter’s birthday in October. It was a success and then some. I believe some friends of friends are considering you already. Thank you for everything.
Orchard Park

Jim, Outstanding catering job last night! Thank you and your staff simply wonderful and everyone said the clams came out perfect! Thanks again 
Bryan Stalk
Association For Facility Engineers
Rochester Chapter 21

Pat and I wanted to thank you for the delicious dinner you prepared for our wedding reception. We received many compliments on the food and the selection. The staff was happy and friendly, you truly were a positive addition and your food was one of the highlights of the evening. I will be sure to recommend you to anyone who asks!
Thanks again!
Sarah Stokoe Burr

On Behalf of the Chapter 44 of the Experimental Aircraft Association I would like to extend our sincere thanks for your assistance in making our recent fly-in breakfast a tremendous success. We received numerous compliments on the quality and variety of the food. Additionally our members appreciated the ease of preparation and service.
Stephen North
Secretary, EAA Chapter 44 

I just wanted to say thank you for making our company Picnic a tremendous success! Everyone loved the food and the service was impressive! The buzz around the stores and office is that this was the best picnic yet. Thanks again and please accept the additional gratuity I am sending.
Pam Salmon, Wendy's Restaurants 

Jim & Kim, thank you very much for the great food we enjoyed at our daughters graduation party on 6/28. It was fresh and delicious and there was plenty of it! We've bragged about it eversince.
Karen & Chris Marchand

Jim & Kim , Thank you again for catering our pig roast! You did an awsome job and everything was wonderful. It was a pleasure working with you. Great Job!
Linda Simmons

 Colby's Staff,
We used you recently for a High School grad party. Everything was wonderful. Ordering was easy, pick-up was very efficient, the staff was friendly and the food was AWESOME !! What a spread. We had so many compliments from our guests and there was plenty of everything. We asked for extra pans so we could make steam tables for the hot foods and put the cold foods on ice. It worked out perfectly. After 5 hours the hot food was still hot and the cold food was still cold.....great for those that came late and wanted a meal. We worried about having too many leftovers (or worse yet, running out of food). Not a problem, and we were glad to have some leftovers as it tasted just as good the next day. Thanks again...we will be telling others about you for their parties.
Brian and Gail Simpson

I just wanted to let you know that the pig roast was a big hit at our family reunion. People had nothing but good things to say about it. The food was delicious and the servers were wonderful. They both were extremely easy going, polite and friendly. Many people commented on how professional and pleasant they were. I would not hesitate to recommend you to anyone. Thank you for helping us have a memorable 50th reunion.
Most Sincerely, Kristin Kojody

Thank you for your services; It truly was the "Best Pig Roast In Rochester 10 years in a row".
Thank You, Gamma Epsilon Tau @ RI

I just wanted to say thank you for the delicious pig roast that you provided to us for our employee appreciation luncheon on July 16, 2009. The food was fabulous and the guys all had great things to say. They asked who catered the food and I was more than happy to give them your name and number!! Thanks again.
Jennifer Scaglia
Hobart and William Smith Colleges
Buildings and Grounds Dept.

Had a wonderful anniversary party at Abilene's downtown Sat night and passed your cards around.
Everyone....loved your food. Fresh and flavorful. I will continue to pass the word.
Thanks for helping us make our party special.
Earl & Mimi Repp

On behalf of all "the Golden Agers" members we want to thank you for the great pig roast on June 17th at Black Creek Park. All the food was delicious, well served and plentiful. You did a superb job and we look forward to seeing you again in the future. 
Thank you again!
The Golden Agers of Chili

Thank You for the great job catering my sons graduation. I never received so many complements in my life about the food and service. As you said the kids were excited to see a real roasted pig. My sister could not believe how much her kids eat! Many people called and asked for your name after the party. I am sure you will be hearing from many of them. 
Thanks Again, Annemarie Ernisse

I just want to take a moment to thank you for catering our summer picnic and Egypt Park on August 25. The food was extraordinary and everything was hot and ready to serve and promised. Our employees only had positive things to say and everyone agreed that we would definitely use you again. Again, thank you for everything that you did to maker our picnic a success. I certainly will not hesitate to recommend your catering services they truly were superb!
Shelley Butts, Enterprise Rent-A-Car

On behalf of the Board of Directors and staff of Mercy Flight Central, I want to thank you for your support of this year's "Ride For Life", motorcycle parade from Harv's Harley-Davison to our base in Canandaigua. The Food was great and the line moved along quickly. 
William Bross, Director of Development

Dear Prospective Customer,
We take pride in catering each event with the same service, quality and attention to detail that has made us famous by word of mouth.... 
We are be pleased to share with you names of customers that we have catered in recently days. Just call Kim at 533-2310. 
Our Past Customers are our Best Advertisement!
Ask your friends about Colby's
Help Us!​
Give us your Ideas & Review
Win A Dinner for Two at Colby's
Restaurant !